The short answer. An assessment is worth it when you need a formal report, for support at school or for funding, and what it costs depends on where you live and what is being tested. If you want to understand why your child is struggling, a test shows you a very narrow slice: how they perform while they know they're being watched. Observation shows you the whole child, and it costs nothing to start.
Key takeaways
- A test measures a child who knows they're being watched, so you see what they think you want.
- A diagnosis is a way of naming something. It doesn't necessarily make it permanent, and it doesn't tell you why it's there.
- Watch first: what they're drawn to, what they avoid and why, and what they tell you. Then take what you've noticed to the right person.
Is an assessment worth the money?
If your child's school needs a formal report before it will give extra support or funding, a report from the right professional opens that door, and it can be worth every dollar. The cost depends on where you live and what is being tested, so before you book, ask what the report will give you and whether the school will accept it.
But if you want to understand why your child is struggling, and what to do about it, a test gives you a slice. A very narrow one. I don't sell assessments. Here's what I look for.
What does a test miss?
Have you ever tried writing an email while someone reads every word over your shoulder as you type? It gets harder, doesn't it? Now imagine that person is deciding what you're capable of.
That's what testing is like for a child. No matter how gently it's done, they're aware that their performance is being observed, and being watched so someone can judge how well you do is even more distressing than being watched. So what goes on the report is how they did in that state, on that day. And every child, whatever their score, walks away with a memory that ties the task to stress.
This is how I describe the difference:
"Testing shows a very narrow range of what is actually going on, while observation (especially when the children don't know I'm observing) gives a whole other level of info, because it's the time when they're not giving me what they think I want. I get to see them in their natural environment. It's like the difference between setting up a hidden camera in the wild, and assessing a tiger in captivity with a tick-list, or making it jump through hoola-hoops, and saying this is what a tiger does."
When I meet a child, I like to watch them first, before I hear what the adults have to say, so I get a clean impression.
One morning I watched the children at a school while the whole school played together. The adults there described one little boy, about four, as "totally disconnected". I watched him tell his friend four times not to do something. Then his friend got upset and walked off, and this boy followed him, put an arm around him and told him it was ok.
"Totally disconnected" wasn't what I saw. The thing I want you to take from this is that observing shows you far more about a child than testing. (I've done my share of both, and I know 100% which is more valuable to creating solutions rather than naming problems.)
What does a diagnosis give you?
A name, and sometimes that's a relief. Naming and acknowledging certain conditions has helped with acceptance and adaptation, and with creating opportunities for children who might otherwise have been left behind or misunderstood.
But a diagnosis is a way of naming something, and it doesn't necessarily make it permanent. A child is always changing. I see so many parents saying their child IS this or that label, and when children hear the adults around them talk that way, it becomes awkward for them to change, even when they want to. If you adopt a label, make it a "peel-off" label.
"Observing shows you far more about a child than testing."
And a name doesn't tell you why it's there. Humans are preconditioned to learn, so when something is harder than it should be, the job is to find out why. That means looking at the component skills underneath it, which I call the 7 Seeds of Success®.
How do you observe your own child?
What I always teach first is to watch. Look at what they're naturally drawn to, and what they avoid. Then ask yourself why they avoid it: is it not of interest, or is it, for some reason, too hard?
Listen to what they tell you, especially what sounds like an excuse. A ten-year-old once told me that when he looks at words, they move around on the page. His mum thought he was making it up. I don't think a child would make that up - they simply wouldn't know to go there. It's a common way a child with a visual focus gap describes what they see. (More on why a bright child can struggle to focus, and why some children can't sit still.)
If you feel a professional is needed, take what you've noticed with you, to someone who looks for where the cause is. The people I point families to are behavioural optometrists (I worked as one for 30 years) and practitioners trained in Rhythmic Movement Training (RMTi). Contact us at hello@wisdomeducation.org for suggestions of where to go.
Frequently asked questions
Is an assessment worth it, and what does it cost?
When you need a formal report for support or funding, yes, and the cost depends on where you live and what is being tested. To understand why your child is struggling, start by observing them.
Do you offer assessments?
No. I point families to behavioural optometrists and RMTi practitioners.
Will a diagnosis stay with my child for life?
A diagnosis is a way of naming a condition, and it doesn't necessarily make it permanent. Use it for the support it opens up, and keep looking for why it's there.
What should I watch for?
What they're drawn to, what they avoid and why, and what sounds like an excuse. Watch when they don't know you're watching.
So what are you watching for?
Seven Seeds, three levels, twenty-one skills that every human needs to have, because they make everything else fall into place. Once you know them, you'll start to see far more in your child's ordinary day. Read about them in the 7 Seeds Framework.
To learn to see your child this way, day by day, start with the Raise Brilliant Kids Program.
New pieces land as they're written.
Join the list and read them first.